ValtorPartnersESContact
A cargo ship moored on a river beside a small town with a domed church.

Note, 3 min read

4 figures, 8 sources

Ships are sinking off NATO's Black Sea coast. Wheat is at a two-month low.

Drone strikes near Bulgaria and Romania have killed or left missing at least 23 sailors in ten days. Chicago wheat fell 6% over the same stretch. The cost is showing up in war-risk quotes and in small bulkers' cargo books, not in grain prices.

A cargo ship on the Danube at Sulina, Romania, where the river meets the Black Sea, July 2012. Nenea hartia, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Sailors missing or dead in drone strikes off Bulgaria and Romania At least 23 in ten days, plus 7 missing from Wine Trader . Reuters, via gCaptain On 14 and 15 October drones struck two chemical tankers anchored near the mouth of the Sulina canal, where the Danube meets the Black Sea. The San Marino-flagged Wine Trader was hit one mile outside Romanian waters; seven of its twelve crew were missing. Romania’s president, Nicusor Dan, said the ships had been struck by drones but declined to say whether Russia was responsible. A NATO military source told Reuters the drones “were of Russian origin”. Reuters counted at least five other cargo ships hit near Romania and Bulgaria in the previous ten days, with “at least 23 sailors reported missing or dead”. On 17 October Romanian F-16s shot down two drones over the country’s territorial waters. The defence ministry did not say where they came from.

The worst came off Bulgaria. On 13 October the Guinea-Bissau-flagged HS Dignity sank near Krapets; eleven crew were missing. A week earlier, nine Syrian sailors and one Egyptian were lost when another ship sank in Bulgaria’s exclusive economic zone. Bulgaria summoned Russia’s ambassador. “There’s no logic in Ukraine destroying its own ships, and the results of these strikes work to Russia’s advantage,” Prime Minister Rumen Radev’s office said. The ambassador said she had no information from Russia’s defence ministry and did not rule out a provocation by a third country, according to the same statement. Romania’s foreign minister, Oana Toiu, called the Black Sea “the deadliest sea when it comes to the number of casualties of sailors in the last months.”

CBOT wheat, December contract 660.50 c/bu, -6.2% from 704.25 on 6 Oct . CBOT delayed data, via Yahoo Finance; Trading Economics Wheat went the other way. December wheat in Chicago settled at 660.50 cents a bushel on 16 October, down 6.2% from 704.25 on 6 October and its lowest close since mid-August. On the day HS Dignity sank, “wheat prices were mostly steady”, Bloomberg reported. “More attacks don’t really alter the picture much,” said Mike Verdin of CRM AgriCommodities. Prices rebounded briefly as traders weighed the Romanian tanker strikes, Trading Economics noted, before Friday’s fall, which it put down to early assessments of “a significantly larger Australian harvest”.

Black Sea hull war-risk quotes 0.6–1.0% of value before discount (0.2–0.5% a week earlier) . BPG Shipping, via Signal Group Black Sea steel loadings, September 20,690 t, -96% y/y . Signal Group The cost is landing elsewhere. Hull war-risk quotes for the Black Sea rose to 0.6–1.0% of a ship’s value before discounts in the week to 9 October, from 0.2–0.5% a week earlier, according to broker figures cited by Signal Group. A broker report on 13 October showed more enquiries for war-risk cover but no new range. Radev’s office said the attacks have already brought “higher insurance costs, and even refusals to transport cargo to Bulgarian ports.” Steel shows the damage most clearly: recorded Black Sea steel loadings fell 96% year on year in September, to 20,690 tonnes, and small bulkers carried 91% of Ukraine’s recorded steel tonnes this year.

Valtor’s inference Our reading, which is an inference: the ships being hit are general cargo ships and small tankers, several anchored or sailing close to NATO coasts, not large grain carriers loading at Odesa. One ship hit the week before, in Romania’s economic zone, was carrying corn, Bloomberg reported; its size was not given. That spares the grain price and puts the cost on the margins of the trade: insurers, small bulkers, steel, and the Danube ports Ukraine now leans on. Grain is also moving less by volume this season: Ukraine exported 5.44 million tonnes of grain and pulses by 7 October, 24.3% less than a year earlier, with wheat down 42%. For now the wheat market is pricing supply from Australia, not risk in the Black Sea.

What to watch

  • A large loaded grain carrier hit. That would test the market’s calm directly.
  • War-risk quotes. A move above the 1% top of the latest range would show insurers pricing the strikes as a lasting feature of the route, not a spike.
  • Bulgaria’s proposed moratorium on attacks on civilian ships, which Radev said EU leaders would discuss.

The Black Sea has become a shooting gallery for small ships. The wheat price will notice only when a big one is hit.

Figures in this piece

Each also stands in the margin beside the paragraph that states it.

  1. 660.50 c/bu, -6.2% from 704.25 on 6 OctCBOT wheat, December contract. CBOT delayed data, via Yahoo Finance; Trading Economics
  2. At least 23 in ten days, plus 7 missing from Wine TraderSailors missing or dead in drone strikes off Bulgaria and Romania. Reuters, via gCaptain
  3. 0.6–1.0% of value before discount (0.2–0.5% a week earlier)Black Sea hull war-risk quotes. BPG Shipping, via Signal Group
  4. 20,690 t, -96% y/yBlack Sea steel loadings, September. Signal Group

Filed under Russia–Ukraine war.

A number here looks wrong? Send a correction. How corrections are handled.